Warriors: Omen of the Stars #4: Sign of the Moon audiobook

I think this book is very good so far. I am almost done with it, it is very mysterious and evil. You want billions of things to happen and others to not, but you cant because all the things have already been written. For example: You dont want any other cat of ThunderClan to join the Dark Forest, but Millie is too concerned of Briarlight that she doesnt notice how much Blossomfall and maybe Bumblestripe are hurt by it. So Blossomfall goes and joins the Dark Forest from hurt and hatred. Blossomfall thinks she is doing the right thing but is blinded by hatred for her mother, she thinks that she will be a stronger better warrior, but doesnt realize the terrible mistake she has done, what all her Clanmates will think of her. Blossomfall does not know she will be killing innocent cats. She thinks doing this will cost her nothing. It will cost her her friends, her family, her Clanmates, her Clan, the forest! She thinks there will be no cost what so ever she probably doesnt even realize it will cost her her life. ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… Oh, no. It costs a lot more than your life. To kill innocent cats? It costs everything you are.

i enjoyed reading this book. its made me think about cats in a whole new way. i like this book because it got me to think about my own lifelike and how its very much like the cat life. i don't mean people are dying because they want to take someones land. i mean these cats have so much faith in starclan they are willing to devote there entire life to them and its like that with people too they have so much faith in their gods they would do anything for them blindley and without question. mothwing (riverclan's medicen cat) shows something that also happens with people the she-cat does not belev in starclan. this is something that happens very often with people, they are told something their whole life but when their older they stop beleving in it. mothwing's leader mistystar has learnd to ecseped that and they bolth live with an understanding of what the other needs this is what happens with people and their religends.

There are many things that I enjoyed in 'Sign of the Moon'. I like reading from Ivypool's point of view. It's really hard for her to come to Dark Forest every night and spy, but she takes this burden to protect her Clan, and that shows what a strong character Ivypool has became. I like the journey to the mountains since it allowed us to see old friends like Stormfur and Brook and gave us one more insight into the Tribe's life. I really love the link between ancient cats, the Tribe of Rushing Water and forest Clans, and I like how the prophecy changes. I enjoyed Jayfeather's (view spoiler)[journey into the past and his life among ancient cats, though he is not my favourite. Seeing the travellers learning new things and adapting to live in the mountains is probably my favourite part of the book. Can I have more about the ancients, please? (hide spoiler)]However, there were some things that kind of annoyed me. It just looks like some cats act out-of-character to deliberately make things difficult. Like Cinderheart building a wall between her and Lionblaze instead of helping by giving him support and encouragement. And though I can understand Millie's behaviour, it still looks just like an excuse to justify Blossomfall's actions, except it doesn't really justify them. Apparently Bumblestripe doesn't complain about lack of attention from his mother and devotes himself to encouraging Briarlight instead. I also hoped for more interaction with the intruders. While the single encounter they had did imply that the Tribe and the intruders can turn from enemies to something else, I hoped to learn more about those strange cats and their way of life. And the most important, I don't like that (view spoiler)[Stoneteller loses his faith in the Tribe of Endless Hunting. The Tribe of Rushing Water survived Sharptooth and remained strong. It was quite shaken when it faced intruders, but that was justified since they had never met such a threat. Still, they survived it. Right now, the Tribe fares rather well, and its problems with intruders are minor ones. Still, Stoneteller loses his faith and neglects his ancestors. Couldn't Jayfeather and company visit the Tribe without saving it once more? And even then, why the Tribe of Endless Hunting trusted Jayfeather - a cat that was in mountains only twice - to chose a new Stoneteller instead of doing it themselves, since they've watched over the cats in mountains for all their lives? I do agree with Jayfeather's judgement, I just think the Tribe's ancestors should've appointed the new Stoneteller themselves. (hide spoiler)]

this was definitely my favorite book of omen of the stars so far, I found it really sad that Jayfeather/ Jay's wing couldn't be with halfmoon. I also noticed that stone song calls Jay's wing Jayfeather without knowing that was his name.

A very good book, the followup to Erin hunter's Night Whispers, book four of the Omen of the Stars Series. I really like all the action in this one, and the interesting thing sthat you find out about other characters. Jayfeather also goes back to the Anicent Tribe (Half Moon, Stone Song) and visits them. I can't wait for the next book!!!!!!

I love these books!

Had a bit of a slow start that made me put it down for a while, but the middle portion of the book was very compelling. I like how the Erins are portraying the Tribe as something in itself that needs to work hard to exist, but I'm still not 100% convinced that they have to be there just because they /have/ to, if that makes sense? Perhaps future volumes will explain. What I did really enjoy was the storyline that's emerging from Ivypool's end.

As with my other recent reads, this book took me FOREVER to read (I blame my schoolwork). That said, I was able to sit down and read the last 50 pages in one sitting which was nice, and I enjoyed it just as much as the others. Two more to go in this series!